Categories

If you are a copyright owner and believe that your copyrighted works have been used in a way that constitutes copyright infringement, here is our DMCA Notice.

« Over the Hil | Main | 2008 Changes are 2006 Changes (video) »

February 01, 2008

Comments

jdh

lichtzwang chick shows her boobs on her profile haha... germans. mary bragg better get out DA VOTE.

Kim

pumped

brian cullen

am also up at youtube.com/proprock. would like to get in on your voting.
new song on britney still not up. snowball

SNAFT

Buffalo by Tom Bone Jenkins is the only thing here worth a damn!! Everything else is overproduced and slicked-out!!

Nurvin Ramtool

oh poor Snaft...sorry, but did you really listen? you couldn't be any more wrong about some...I personally know one band recorded their whole album for less than 500 bucks...
anyway, cool contest! when do we find out the next winner(s)?
thanks...

tom bone jenkins

Hey SNAFT!! Don't say that! Yu're embarrassing me! You're crazy SNAFT!! Sorry folks about SNAFT's rude comment.....

Blubber Glaze

$500? That's an outrage! THE SNAFT is 100% right! I would give 10 lbs of marzipan to here a few more from Tom Bone Jenkins! The rest of them all kind of suck. JMO

Megan

Now now, no need to be mean. I have a naughty step and I'm not afraid to put you on it, Blubby and Snafty.

Spanky Moe Green

I agree with THE SNAFT. The truth does hurt sometimes, but lets all be honest. But marzipan? and "here" instead of "hear"? I don't get that Blubber Glaze.

How does the mediocre garbage get to compete with the Jenkins stuff? THE SNAFT's comments are right on the money. I'm sure the voting is corrupted. I would like to see the actual number of votes. Perhaps some stacking may be involved?!?!?!?!?

SMG

GBV

I gotta say, I think THE STEEDS tune is right on. Good, solid, seemingly simple garage stuff...bringin back a quite nice 60's vibe. Refreshing.
GBV

Spank Moe Green

GBV, after your comment, I gave the steeds a second listen....I could see your point if it weren't so "Mel Bay Book 1". It's still awful.

SMG

kane

yeah, great more 60's based rock?? didnt this burn out in the 70's and again in 2003?

Marshall

There is NO rock music today that isn't reminiscent of something... most of the comments on here seem fairly unfounded and irritatingly negative and rude. That's ashame.
We all have different tastes, and maybe some of the musicians are not your cup-a-tea, but come on, have some class whether it's your bag or not. Variety is the spice of life... be thankful for contests like this which allow for those differences. cheers.
Marshall.

Marshall

There is NO rock music today that isn't reminiscent of something... most of the comments on here seem fairly unfounded and irritatingly negative and rude. That's ashame.
We all have different tastes, and maybe some of the musicians are not your cup-a-tea, but come on, have some class whether it's your bag or not. Variety is the spice of life... be thankful for contests like this which allow for those differences. cheers.
Marshall.

kane

Your right.. We always build of the past.. but I just think its funny that it(indie pop sound) keeps going back to the 60's.. baby boomers.. when will it end?

J.T. Gurley

very interesting discussion going o here....just how "amateur" is this contest? most of you are like accountants on your lunchbreak talkin' music....get outta here and go back to kissin' ass for a living!!

RJ

well, well... listen to Mr. Rock n Roll J.T. Gurley. Please, enlighten the "part-time music peasants" with your non-ass kissin', out of control, livin' on the edge of the brink of music, self. Wait, you probably don't have the time... with organizing your Sonics vinyl, tuning up your hipster '57 Guild, renewing your subscription to Mojo mag., and doing everything music oriented us amateurs could only dream of.

Spanky Moe Green

Marshall....your an ass.

JT I'm quitting my job tomorrow!

You're all losing the point of Pump it or Dump it.

I shouldn't curb my opinions "to be nice" or "understanding of different tastes". If it sucks to me, I'm sorry, it sucks.

Same can be said for my career choices, (by the way I get my ass kissed, not the other way around...I'm the boss!) just because I'm successful in life doesn't mean I can't have an appreciation for music beyond all the commercialized bullshit out there.

All that being said, I personally would hope for an honest opinion of my work/music whatever, so I could take it in a new direction if it sucks. I would rather that than people feigning support so my feelings don't get hurt. If I saw a big old "Dump it" I would appreciate the critisism and move in a new direction.

Perhaps if I'm a Mel Bay Book One, shallow, no talent, I should take that career a little more seriously.

Smoot

Just because the Steeds song sucks doesn't mean its bad.

Maybe that's what they were going for.

Smoot

Daron

did Spanky just say, "I would take my song in a new direction if it sucks"...?? and, "if I saw a big 'ole dump it, I would move in a new direction" ? you would change what you're doing depending on what people thought? Spanky, your ridiculousness is a no-brainer. you're extremely laughable.. please stop now, we're begging you!
Also, you constantly keep making your May Bay Book One reference. The Steeds sound hardly this. And anyway, just because something's "simple" doesn't mean it's bad. There's thousands of examples of this.
I like the Steeds song, and it appears that most people do too... I thought you'd like to know this...because according to your convoluted "dump" logic, bands should change if they're being "dumped." Maybe The Steeds should stay the same since they are getting the opposite votes? Then again, YOU might believe, according to what you said, that they are getting too "commercialized" with their popularity here. See what I mean. Again, you really have to stop before your levity becomes overbearing to all.
Please stop this madness before it snowballs too far, and no one will be able to save you from yourself. Thanks. Now enjoy.......
And by the way, congratulations on your booming career. :-)

Spanky moe green

Thank you Daron, you're right. Crappy musicians should be encouraged to fill the world with mediocre junk. Let's encourage them to stay the coarse and squander other opportunities in lieu of a lucrative music career. Constructive critisism is, and always has been an oxymoron.

Thanks again for setting me straight big guy.

Yours truly,
SMG

Phil Hamm

Very exciting to see this kind of talent out there. Music is a great way to live.

Julie

Hi!
When is this over/do we find out the winner?
Thanks,
JAB

Big Jim & The Twins

Hey Julie, you sound HOT!

Johnny Tyson

The Tom Bone Jenkins song is really cool. Very innovative and poetic.

The comments to this entry are closed.